Top 7 Metrics for Tracking Influencer Engagement
Want to know if your influencer campaigns are working? Start tracking these 7 key metrics. They help you measure engagement, audience connection, and ROI. Here's a quick rundown:
- Engagement Rate: Measures likes, comments, shares, and saves relative to followers. High rates mean better audience connection.
- Engagement by Reach: Tracks interactions compared to how many people actually see the content.
- Engagement by Impressions: Looks at how engaging content is, even after repeated views.
- Audience Growth Rate: Shows how fast an influencer's follower count is growing.
- Shares and Saves Ratio: Indicates how often content is shared (wider reach) or saved (lasting value).
- Click-Through Rate (CTR): Tracks how many people click on links or CTAs in the content.
- Brand Sentiment Analysis: Analyzes audience emotions - positive, neutral, or negative - toward your campaign.
These metrics help brands pick the right influencers, improve content, and maximize ROI. Tools like Influs can automate tracking and make data easier to analyze. Keep in mind that benchmarks differ across platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook, so tailor your goals accordingly.
| Metric | Purpose | How to Use |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement Rate | Measures audience interaction | Compare likes, comments, shares, saves |
| Engagement by Reach | Tracks content visibility | Focus on unique viewers |
| Engagement by Impressions | Assesses repeated content appeal | Compare total views vs. interactions |
| Audience Growth Rate | Measures follower growth | Track new followers over time |
| Shares and Saves Ratio | Tracks virality and value | Compare shares (reach) vs. saves (value) |
| Click-Through Rate (CTR) | Measures conversion intent | Use trackable links for clicks |
| Brand Sentiment Analysis | Gauges audience emotions | Monitor positive, neutral, negative feedback |
How You Can Measure the ROI of Your Influencer Marketing Campaigns Effectively | Michael Pacheco
1. Engagement Rate
Engagement rate serves as a key metric for understanding whether an influencer's audience actively connects with their content. It evaluates the average interactions - such as likes, comments, shares, and saves - relative to an influencer's total followers or reach.
Why Engagement Rate Matters
Engagement rate goes beyond surface-level metrics to reveal how invested an audience is in an influencer's content. For instance, consider two influencers: one with 100,000 followers but only 500 interactions per post, and another with 10,000 followers generating 800 interactions. The second influencer clearly has a more engaged audience, making them a stronger candidate for impactful campaigns. This metric showcases an influencer’s ability to consistently create content that resonates with their audience, fostering a loyal and active community. Such engagement is the foundation for achieving meaningful campaign results.
How It Impacts Campaign Performance
Engagement rate is closely tied to campaign success. A higher rate not only reflects audience interest but also hints at better conversion potential. As Upfluence notes:
"A strong engagement rate means an influencer is likely to generate a positive return on investment and generate real results for your brand." – Upfluence
For example, in March 2023, Farfetch generated over $15.4 million in sales through influencer collaborations, while MercerLabs achieved a 6x ROI with their creator affiliate program. These figures underline how influencers with high engagement rates can drive substantial business outcomes.
Simple to Calculate
Calculating engagement rate is straightforward, though methods can vary by platform. The basic formula divides total engagements by total followers, then multiplies by 100. Some brands prefer to use reach instead of followers to account for algorithmic differences. Tools like Influs simplify this process by offering real-time calculations, trend analysis, and even fake follower detection.
Platform Benchmarks to Keep in Mind
Knowing platform-specific benchmarks helps set realistic goals. TikTok influencers generally see much higher engagement compared to Instagram or YouTube. For example, U.S. TikTok content averages an engagement rate of 17.99%, though projections suggest this may drop to around 2.50% by 2025. On Instagram, micro-influencers with 1,000–5,000 followers often achieve rates as high as 4.6%, while larger accounts average closer to 3%. Facebook and X, by contrast, tend to have much lower engagement rates, hovering around 0.15%, making them less appealing for organic engagement strategies.
Understanding these benchmarks allows brands to tailor their campaigns and select influencers whose engagement aligns with their goals.
2. Engagement by Reach
Engagement by reach measures how well an influencer's content connects with their audience by comparing total interactions to the number of unique viewers. The formula is straightforward: divide the total engagements by the post's reach and multiply by 100. This metric becomes especially useful when content extends beyond an influencer's follower base through searches, shares, or hashtags.
Why It Matters for Influencer Engagement
Unlike traditional engagement rates, which are tied to follower counts, engagement by reach focuses on how many people actually see the content. Influencers who consistently reach large audiences often see higher engagement percentages. This makes it an excellent way to assess how well their content performs, even when it reaches viewers outside their immediate circle.
A Key Indicator of Campaign Success
This metric is a powerful tool for gauging the quality of content and its ability to captivate viewers. A high engagement by reach percentage shows that the content resonates with a broader audience, not just the influencer's followers. For brands, this is invaluable when identifying influencers whose content can generate interest beyond their existing fan base.
Simple to Measure, Easy to Use
Most social media platforms provide reach data through their analytics tools, making this metric easy to calculate. The formula is:
(Total engagements per post / Reach per post) × 100
For campaigns involving multiple posts, brands can calculate the average engagement by reach to get a clearer picture. Tools like Influs simplify this process, automating calculations and saving time - especially when managing campaigns across several influencers and platforms.
Setting Realistic Expectations Across Platforms
Engagement by reach can vary significantly depending on the platform, so understanding benchmarks is essential. This metric offers a more accurate reflection of content visibility compared to follower-based calculations. For instance, in 2024, the average daily engagements per post across industries stood at 14. Tracking this data helps brands spot trends and fine-tune their influencer strategies effectively.
3. Engagement by Impressions
Engagement by impressions measures how effectively content captures interest compared to the total number of times it’s displayed, regardless of whether users interact with it. This metric is calculated by dividing total engagements by total impressions and multiplying the result by 100, giving you a percentage that reflects how appealing the content is.
Impressions count every instance of content being shown, whether it’s to new or returning viewers. This differs from engagement by reach, which focuses on unique viewers only. The distinction is important because impressions provide a broader view of how often content is seen, even if the same user encounters it multiple times.
Relevance to Influencer Engagement
This metric is especially useful for evaluating whether content remains engaging over repeated views. When influencers create attention-grabbing content, it should continue to resonate with audiences as it appears multiple times in feeds or through recommendation algorithms. Engagement by impressions can highlight whether an influencer’s content maintains its appeal or if its effectiveness fades with repeated exposure.
For example, the formula for engagement by impressions looks like this:
(Total engagements ÷ Total impressions) × 100
If a post receives 300 engagements and is displayed 2,000 times, the engagement by impressions rate is 15%. A low percentage compared to engagement by reach might suggest that while the content is being seen often, it isn’t driving additional interactions. This could signal a need to refine the content.
Impact on Campaign Success
For extended campaigns where content is shown repeatedly across platforms, analyzing impressions provides insight into brand recall. High engagement by impressions suggests that the content continues to connect with audiences, even after multiple exposures. This helps brands fine-tune their creative strategies and allocate resources to content that keeps audiences interested over time.
Ease of Measurement
Tracking this metric is straightforward, as most social media platforms include impression data in their analytics tools. Since impressions always equal or exceed reach, it’s helpful to use both metrics together for a more complete understanding of content performance. Tools like Influs simplify these calculations and offer comparative analyses, saving time and ensuring accuracy.
Platform-Specific Benchmarks
Engagement patterns vary across platforms, which can affect impression-based metrics. For instance, TikTok typically sees engagement rates between 2.88% and 7.50%, depending on an influencer’s follower count. Instagram, on the other hand, has engagement rates ranging from 1.77% to 3.65%.
Knowing these benchmarks allows brands to set practical goals and measure their campaigns against platform-specific standards.
4. Audience Growth Rate
Audience growth rate measures how fast an influencer’s follower count grows over a set period. The formula is simple: subtract the starting follower count from the ending count, divide the result by the starting count, and multiply by 100 to get the percentage. For example, if an influencer starts with 10,000 followers and gains 500 in a month, their growth rate is 5%. This metric provides insight into an influencer's growth pattern, offering a foundation for assessing their overall impact on campaigns.
Relevance to Influencer Engagement
Audience growth rate goes hand in hand with engagement quality. It shows whether an influencer’s content is compelling enough to turn casual viewers into loyal followers. When influencers create engaging content, people are more likely to follow them for future updates, reflecting a deeper connection beyond basic interactions like likes or comments. A study of over 10,000 commercial influencer posts found a strong link between audience growth and conversion rates. Influencers generating more than 10 conversions per post had an average growth rate of 3.2%, while others saw slight negative growth (around –0.1%). This highlights how audience growth can signal an influencer’s potential to drive meaningful actions.
Impact on Campaign Success
Tracking audience growth during campaigns helps brands gauge whether collaborations are building a lasting community rather than just causing short-term spikes in sales or engagement. A rising growth rate indicates that the partnership is attracting a loyal audience. When an influencer gains followers during a campaign, it suggests the content resonates with viewers who are genuinely interested. Brands should also evaluate if these new followers align with their target demographics and are likely to stay engaged. In the long run, a growing and loyal follower base enhances brand recall and creates more opportunities for exposure.
Ease of Measurement
Measuring audience growth is straightforward since most social media platforms provide follower count data through their analytics tools. Platforms like Influs make this process even easier by automating calculations and offering comparative analyses across influencers and campaigns.
Platform-Specific Benchmarks
Knowing the typical growth rates for each platform helps set realistic goals and assess performance effectively. For instance, a study on Instagram influencer posts found that general performers often see minimal or even negative growth (around –0.1% monthly), while top performers average a growth rate of 3.2%. Growth benchmarks for other platforms include:
| Platform | Average Monthly Growth Rate (General) | High-Performance Benchmark |
|---|---|---|
| –0.1% | 3.2% | |
| 1% – 3% | 5% – 10% | |
| 0.5% – 1% | 2% – 3% |
Larger accounts tend to grow at a slower percentage rate due to their already high follower counts.
These benchmarks vary based on factors like industry, audience size, and content strategy. For example, e-commerce brands might aim for annual growth rates between 20% and 30%, while nonprofits typically see around 15% growth. By combining audience growth data with other engagement metrics, brands can create more informed and effective influencer marketing strategies.
sbb-itb-0e1095d
5. Shares and Saves Ratio
The shares and saves ratio measures how often users share content compared to saving it for later. While shares reflect active endorsement, saves highlight the lasting value of content. Together, these metrics offer a deeper understanding of content performance, going beyond the surface-level insights from likes or comments.
Relevance to Influencer Engagement
This ratio provides a window into audience behavior. Shares amplify reach as users essentially vouch for the content by sharing it with their network, making it a strong sign of engagement. This type of interaction helps influencers extend their message far beyond their immediate followers.
On the other hand, saves indicate that the content resonates on a deeper level. When someone saves a post, it signals that the content holds value worth revisiting. These metrics can reveal interesting patterns - for instance, a post with many shares but few likes or comments might suggest it’s being widely distributed but not sparking deeper conversations.
"We're moving more into the era of the silent viewers, the doom scrollers and attention will be even harder to have than before. We'll see more movement towards dark social as generations value their privacy more and more. But in the DMs and the closed groups, sharing of content will thrive. Making content that addresses real challenges is more important than ever before."
– Beth Thomas, Director of Social @ Frankly
By understanding these behaviors, brands can better use shares and saves to expand their reach and refine their campaigns.
Impact on Campaign Success
The shares and saves ratio can significantly enhance campaign ROI by increasing content reach without additional ad spend. When influencer content is shared, it gains exposure to new audiences, creating organic amplification that boosts overall campaign performance. In fact, influencer marketing spend in the U.S. has nearly doubled over the past three years, with an average ROI of $5 to $6.50 for every dollar invested.
Saves, meanwhile, play a key role in long-term brand recall. They create multiple touchpoints that allow potential customers to interact with the content at their own pace, moving them further along the sales funnel. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for optimizing influencer strategies.
Ease of Measurement
Tracking shares and saves accurately is essential for refining campaigns. However, the ease of measurement varies across platforms. Instagram, for instance, provides detailed insights into saves via Creator Studio, while TikTok focuses more on share metrics. Tools like Influs help simplify the process by aggregating share and save data across various platforms.
Platform-Specific Benchmarks
Sharing and saving behaviors differ widely depending on the platform:
- TikTok: Shares have doubled year over year in 2025, reflecting the platform's focus on rapid engagement growth.
- Instagram: Sharing patterns remain steady, with an average of 41 shares per post.
- Facebook: Share activity has declined slightly, dropping from 15 shares per post in 2023 to 13 in 2024.
According to Hootsuite’s 2024 Consumer Report, 44% of people share content because they agree with it, 29% share to spread information, and 24% share inspirational posts.
"Sharing a piece of content is an emotional response and a testament to how well your content landed."
– Trish Riswick, Social Media Manager, Hootsuite
To encourage more shares and saves, brands can use strategic calls-to-action in captions, like “Tag someone who needs this!” or “Share this with a friend!” By addressing real challenges and offering meaningful value, influencers can inspire both actions, amplifying their campaign’s message.
6. Click-Through Rate (CTR)
After diving into metrics like engagement and reach, Click-Through Rate (CTR) steps in as a key indicator of conversion intent. It measures how many people actively click on links or calls-to-action (CTAs) within influencer content, showcasing interest that goes beyond passive reactions such as likes or comments.
To calculate CTR, use this formula: divide the total number of clicks by the total number of impressions, then multiply by 100. For example, if a sponsored post garners 1,000 impressions and 100 clicks, the CTR would be 10%.
Why CTR Matters for Influencer Engagement
CTR bridges the gap between audience awareness and actual conversion. While other metrics reflect how people engage with content, CTR reveals whether an influencer’s audience trusts their recommendations enough to act on them. Micro-influencers often see higher CTRs because their niche audiences tend to be more engaged and aligned with specific interests. This alignment can lead to stronger click-through performance and better resonance with your brand’s message, ultimately driving higher returns on investment (ROI).
How CTR Impacts Campaign Success
CTR is closely tied to campaign ROI. A higher CTR means more traffic to your website or landing pages, which translates into more opportunities for conversions. When influencer content achieves strong CTRs, it’s a clear sign that the partnership is effectively driving action. Brands can use these results to confidently scale their collaborations and allocate more budget to influencers who consistently deliver results.
Measuring CTR Effectively
Accurate CTR tracking requires unique, trackable links for each influencer. These links ensure that every click is attributed correctly. Tools like Influs simplify this process by offering analytics that track clicks across various social media platforms. Regularly monitoring CTR data helps brands identify high-performing influencers and campaigns that may need adjustments. This data-driven approach ensures resources are focused where they’ll have the most impact.
Platform-Specific CTR Benchmarks
CTR performance varies widely across platforms, so platform-specific benchmarks are crucial for evaluating campaigns. For instance:
- Instagram: Typical CTRs range from 0.22% to 0.88% for most campaigns.
- TikTok: CTRs are often higher, ranging from 0.5% to 1.5%, depending on the niche and content strategy.
Industry type also affects CTR expectations. In 2024, dental offices reported average CTRs of 5.38%, while travel agencies reached an impressive 10.16%. Email marketing campaigns, on the other hand, currently average around 3.42%.
For mobile app campaigns, CTRs can differ between operating systems. iOS apps consistently outperform Android, with iOS games achieving CTRs of 4.27% compared to Android’s 3.34%, and iOS apps reaching 3.01% versus Android’s 2.43%.
Tips to Improve CTR
Boosting CTR often comes down to crafting compelling CTAs that clearly outline the benefits of clicking. Testing different ad copy, keywords, and design elements can also make a significant difference. A/B testing these components ensures that your campaigns are optimized for the best possible performance.
7. Brand Sentiment Analysis
Brand sentiment analysis goes beyond tracking likes and comments - it dives into the emotions your audience feels about your brand and influencer collaborations. By leveraging NLP (Natural Language Processing) and AI, this method evaluates comments, captions, and even emojis to classify reactions as positive, neutral, or negative. It’s smart enough to pick up on sarcasm, understand context, and detect subtle emotional undertones that traditional metrics might miss.
Relevance to Influencer Engagement
When it comes to influencer partnerships, sentiment analysis shifts the focus from quantity to quality. Take this example: a lifestyle brand worked with two influencers who posted similar content. One influencer received overwhelmingly positive feedback, while the other faced criticism. Thanks to sentiment analysis, the brand adjusted its messaging to better resonate with its audience. Considering that 86% of consumers make purchases influenced by social media at least once a year, understanding audience emotions can be the difference between a campaign's success or failure.
Impact on Campaign Success
Sentiment can make or break a campaign. Negative reviews can slash sales by 15%, while positive ones can drive increases of 32% to 52%. Moreover, 94% of consumers avoid businesses with poor reviews. Sentiment analysis acts as an early warning system. For instance, in 2012, McDonald's faced backlash when its #McDStories hashtag was hijacked on Twitter. Quick sentiment monitoring allowed the brand to pull the campaign within two hours, minimizing damage. In another case, a brand paused a product launch mid-campaign after sentiment data revealed confusion about how to use the product. A timely how-to post turned things around, boosting conversions.
Ease of Measurement
Tracking audience sentiment has never been easier. Tools like Influs integrate sentiment monitoring into campaign analytics, automatically categorizing mentions and comments as positive, neutral, or negative. Regular tracking - such as weekly sentiment reviews - and real-time social listening can reveal valuable insights into audience perception. Quick polls can also complement automated tools, giving brands a direct way to gauge audience emotions and fine-tune campaigns. This streamlined process enables brands to compare performance across platforms and adjust strategies accordingly.
Platform-Specific Benchmarks
Different social platforms evoke different emotional responses, making platform-specific sentiment analysis crucial. TikTok, with its entertainment-driven content, tends to spark more emotional reactions, while LinkedIn generates more professional, measured feedback. For example, Dunkin' Donuts’ campaign offering free coffee to educators on World Teachers' Day saw "free coffee" emerge as a top driver of positive sentiment within 30 days. Meanwhile, United Airlines faced negative sentiment centered around "lose luggage", highlighting a key customer pain point. Nivea, on the other hand, achieved nearly 100% positive sentiment during its "Living in My Skin" podcast series by closely monitoring emotional responses. Including sentiment analysis in post-campaign reviews - alongside metrics like reach and clicks - helps brands identify creators who consistently drive positive engagement.
Metrics Comparison Table
Understanding the benchmarks for key engagement metrics can be the difference between a campaign that thrives and one that falls flat. The table below outlines seven critical engagement metrics, offering benchmark figures and platform-specific insights. Use this as a quick reference to evaluate and compare your performance across different social channels.
| Metric | TikTok | X (Twitter) | Primary Use Case | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engagement Rate | 0.50% (avg) 3%+ (good) 5%+ (excellent) |
2.50% (avg) 3%+ (good) 5%+ (exceptional) |
0.15% (avg) 1.4% (across industries) 3%+ (good) |
0.15% (avg) 1.6% (across industries) 2%+ (good) |
2.8% (avg) 3%+ (good) |
Building brand awareness and fostering community |
| Engagement by Reach | Total Engagements ÷ Reach × 100 | High engagement driven by algorithms | Limited organic reach - requires paid promotion | Limited organic reach | Effective for professional audiences | Evaluating content effectiveness |
| Engagement by Impressions | Total Engagements ÷ Impressions × 100 | 6,268 avg impressions per post | Often depends on paid promotion | Limited organic impressions | Steady visibility in B2B sectors | Assessing content visibility |
| Audience Growth Rate | Growth varies by audience size: Nano (1K–10K): 2.19% Micro (10K–50K): 0.99% |
- | - | - | - | Long-term growth and brand building |
| Shares/Saves Ratio | 41 shares per post (avg) | Shares have doubled year-over-year | - | - | - | Measuring virality and content value |
| Click-Through Rate (CTR) | Feed: 0.22%–0.88% Stories: 0.33%–0.54% |
Not applicable for organic; focus on profile visits | 0.90% (avg across industries) | - | 0.52% (avg across industries) | Driving direct conversions |
| Brand Sentiment | Strong for lifestyle and visual content | High emotional engagement, entertainment-driven | Mixed sentiment | Real-time sentiment tracking | Professional, balanced feedback | Managing campaign risks |
Key Observations from the Data
TikTok leads the way in organic engagement, with like counts up to nine times higher than Instagram. However, Instagram now demands more strategic, reach-oriented content to remain effective. LinkedIn's consistent engagement rate of 2.8% makes it a go-to platform for B2B campaigns, whereas Facebook and X require a blend of organic and paid strategies to achieve meaningful outcomes.
The Role of Influencer Size in Performance
Follower count plays a crucial role in determining metric benchmarks. Nano-influencers, for instance, boast engagement rates of around 2.19% and often deliver stronger ROI compared to celebrity influencers, whose rates average 0.94%. A study revealed that nano-influencers convert 7% of engagements into sales, outperforming macro-influencers, who achieve a 3% conversion rate.
Aligning Metrics with Campaign Goals
Each metric aligns with specific campaign objectives. For brand awareness, prioritize metrics like reach, impressions, and engagement rate. If your goal is direct conversions, focus on CTR, audience growth rate, and sentiment analysis - especially on platforms like LinkedIn, which attract high-intent users. Tailoring your metrics to your campaign's purpose ensures maximum ROI.
It's important to evaluate your performance against platform-specific benchmarks rather than expecting uniform standards. For instance, a 1% engagement rate might be strong on Facebook but could indicate underperformance on TikTok, where the average is 2.50%.
Conclusion
From the data we've explored, one thing is clear: precise tracking is the backbone of successful campaigns. By focusing on these seven engagement metrics, you can gain a full view of performance - whether it's gauging how well your content connects with audiences or assessing the direct impact on business outcomes.
With 86% of companies planning to leverage influencer marketing this year, understanding these metrics can give you a serious edge. Influencer marketing is reported to be 10.52 times more cost-effective than paid media, making it critical to track the right data to demonstrate value to stakeholders.
"When you're trying to report the success of the entire program to C-level execs, the board, or investors, what does that look like? What does success look like for these programs, and how do you have that conversation internally? What metrics are you leaning on to tell that story?"
- Korina Sanchez, Performance Marketing Manager at Chomps
Rather than tracking every possible data point, focus on metrics that directly align with your campaign goals. Experts agree that your objectives dictate which metrics matter most.
Tools like Influs simplify this process by aggregating data from multiple influencers into one dashboard, allowing for real-time tracking and quick adjustments. This means less time spent on manual data collection and more time refining your strategy.
Successful brands adopt a holistic tracking approach. Molly Savage, Omnichannel Growth Marketing Leader at Bobabam, highlights the importance of combining multiple metrics:
"We look at digital sampling, in-store sales velocity, promo codes, and unique URLs, to name a few. This is in addition to impressions and engagement metrics we're viewing on social. It's powerful when you can marry multiple metrics together to tell a story where they may have lived in isolation before"
The takeaway? Consistent tracking is essential for keeping your campaigns effective across platforms. Begin with the metric that aligns most closely with your main objective, and as your program evolves, expand your tracking efforts. By weaving these metrics into your strategy, you create a solid framework for long-term success.
FAQs
What engagement metrics should brands use to choose the right influencers for their campaigns?
Brands can find the right influencers by paying close attention to engagement metrics like engagement rate, audience demographics, and the quality of their content. The engagement rate - calculated by dividing total interactions (likes, comments, shares) by the influencer's follower count - offers insight into how well they connect with their audience. Generally, a higher engagement rate indicates stronger trust and a better chance of driving conversions.
It's also crucial to evaluate audience demographics to ensure the influencer's followers match the brand's target audience. This alignment plays a big role in making campaigns more relevant and impactful. By digging into these metrics, brands can confidently choose influencers who are a great fit for their goals and build partnerships that deliver results.
What are the typical engagement benchmarks for social media platforms, and why do they matter in influencer marketing?
Engagement rates differ significantly across social media platforms, with TikTok currently leading the pack at an average rate of 2.50%. Instagram trails behind at 0.50%, while Facebook and X (formerly Twitter) sit much lower at 0.15% each. Notably, Instagram has experienced a 28% year-over-year drop in engagement, highlighting a broader trend of declining interaction rates.
Why do these benchmarks matter? They serve as a critical measure of success in influencer marketing. A higher engagement rate suggests that an influencer is resonating with their audience, fostering trust and loyalty. This connection often translates into increased brand awareness, deeper customer relationships, and better returns on investment for marketing campaigns.
How can brands use sentiment analysis to improve influencer campaigns?
Sentiment analysis gives brands a clearer picture of how audiences feel about influencer content. By examining emotional reactions - whether positive, negative, or neutral - brands can pinpoint influencers who share their values and drive genuine engagement.
This kind of data helps marketers refine their campaigns to better connect with their target audience. Plus, by keeping an eye on sentiment over time, brands can adjust their strategies as needed, ensuring their campaigns stay relevant and continue to resonate as audience preferences shift.
